| | Acid trap hole and dust tornado | |
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
AnimeDingo Obelisk Dorm


Posts: 153 Age: 18 Location: Seattle Wa Join date: 2010-11-11
 | Subject: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 11/23/2010, 4:23 pm | |
| I activate acid trap hole and then the opponent activates dust tornado. what happens? |
|
 | |
HallowMan1391 Obelisk Dorm

Posts: 46 Age: 21 Join date: 2010-11-01
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 11/23/2010, 6:48 pm | |
| Acid Trap Hole does its thing and Dust Tornado was wasted. (That is assuming Dust Tornado was activated on ATH) Dust Tornado just destroys it does not negate |
|
 | |
AnimeDingo Obelisk Dorm


Posts: 153 Age: 18 Location: Seattle Wa Join date: 2010-11-11
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 11/23/2010, 7:03 pm | |
| thats what i thought but the guy i was playing said that since it wasnt a "chain" my effect was negated |
|
 | |
HallowMan1391 Obelisk Dorm

Posts: 46 Age: 21 Join date: 2010-11-01
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 11/23/2010, 7:04 pm | |
| |
|
 | |
brettbstock Obelisk Dorm Leader


Posts: 252 Age: 14 Location: Outer Space Join date: 2010-10-20
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 11/24/2010, 7:59 am | |
| Question answered. Topic locked. _________________ Tonight, I will attempt to go back in time. You will know I have succeeded when Germany loses World War 2, and Tuesday comes before Wednesday.  |
|
 | |
brettbstock Obelisk Dorm Leader


Posts: 252 Age: 14 Location: Outer Space Join date: 2010-10-20
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/6/2011, 9:27 pm | |
| Someone has declared this ruling incorrect. I'll re-open the topic for a few days to be sure we have the correct ruling. _________________ Tonight, I will attempt to go back in time. You will know I have succeeded when Germany loses World War 2, and Tuesday comes before Wednesday.  |
|
 | |
Asriel Slifer Dorm


Posts: 19 Join date: 2011-01-06
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/6/2011, 10:22 pm | |
| | HallowMan1391 wrote: | | Acid Trap Hole does its thing and Dust Tornado was wasted. (That is assuming Dust Tornado was activated on ATH) Dust Tornado just destroys it does not negate |
is correct |
|
 | |
deck master Ra Dorm Leader


Posts: 210 Age: 17 Location: k-town, NY Join date: 2010-12-24
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/7/2011, 12:06 pm | |
| ive looked at many different points and i discussed this with hallow... mystical space typhoon and dust tornado dont need to say negate cause they remove the card off the field before the cards eff resolves.... therefor the chain can not resolve acid TH eff |
|
 | |
Goku Slifer Dorm


Posts: 38 Age: 19 Location: Athens, Greece Join date: 2010-12-26
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/7/2011, 2:20 pm | |
| there is no discussion things etc guys. I am a real life player many years and this is how it is : When cards are chained to trap spells or effect monsters if they dont write the word NEGATE they do not negate them. Yea mst and dust destroy xards but their effect resolves cause they dont negate them. I know the logic things says that since they destroy them and its chain link 2 they should not activate. But to answer this ask konami. Thats the reason of the existance of cards like Dark Bribe and Solemn cause they negate and thats why they have big costs.
http://yugioh.wikia.com/wiki/Card_Rulings:Mystical_Space_Typhoon#OCG_Rulings
Visit this link and go down the page at OCG rulings and read the first ruling. Its clear. |
|
 | |
AnimeDingo Obelisk Dorm


Posts: 153 Age: 18 Location: Seattle Wa Join date: 2010-11-11
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/7/2011, 4:33 pm | |
| |
|
 | |
brettbstock Obelisk Dorm Leader


Posts: 252 Age: 14 Location: Outer Space Join date: 2010-10-20
 | Subject: Re: Acid trap hole and dust tornado 1/7/2011, 4:50 pm | |
| | AnimeDingo wrote: | | so... topic closed? |
I guess so. Topic Closed._________________ Tonight, I will attempt to go back in time. You will know I have succeeded when Germany loses World War 2, and Tuesday comes before Wednesday.  |
|
 | |
| | Acid trap hole and dust tornado | |
|